The Suez Canal Legal Fight


Ever Given

by Carlos Luxul author of The Ocean Dove

As the saga of the Ever Given in the Suez canal rumbles on, one thing has struck me: why haven’t we heard anything about a class-action law suit against the Suez Canal Authority (SCA) from a collective of the frustrated shippers and receivers? 

I haven’t seen the manifest but with around 20,000 TEUs on board, it stands to reason that many of the world’s leading corporations are likely to have been caught up in this - and while they may have a lot of power individually, they will have even more as a consortium. 

While I’m no lawyer, it seems to me that the SCA is already guilty of flouting certain international laws and conventions. They are also making arbitrary and unreasonable claims against the ship’s ownership structure and, more specifically, the innocent parties caught up in it - the beneficial cargo owners. All this suggests there are solid grounds for action. Surely there’s an international commercial court or institution that would take up the case, and surely a leading law firm would want to head it up?

Litigation (Pic: Scot Graham)

There’s plenty of scope: a court ruling to release the containers; damages for trade disruption; sanctions against the SCA; liens against their assets; restrictive orders against their leading personnel; and no doubt a good lawyer can add ten further claim categories in the time it takes to have a cup of coffee.

So far we’ve seen the usual pleas from the ship’s owners, the charterers, managers, flag, P&I Club and underwriters, and they’ve all fallen on deaf ears – as would be expected. So what’s stopping it? Is the legal ground shaky or are the beneficial cargo owners running scared of punitive action in the future from the SCA, who might try to restrict their future cargoes from transiting the canal?

In today’s litigious world, I’m surprised not to have heard any suggestion of legal action in the media, though perhaps it’s been discussed in private. So, all you lawyers out there, can you throw any light on it - would a class-action law suit work or is it already dead in the water? I’d love to see a reasoned opinion on the pros and cons, and I suspect everyone else would too.

CarlosLuxul

Carlos Luxul’s novel, The Ocean Dove, is a tense maritime terrorism thriller, charting brilliantly how shipping’s loose regulatory framework could be used for carnage. 

www.carlosluxul.com.

 

Location: Egypt

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

How The X-Press Pearl Disaster Could Have Been Avoided

Image
  SPLASH: The X-Press Pearl Disaster X-Press Pearl by Carlos Luxul author of The Ocean Dove The X-Press Pearl  sank on June 2 in what is now referred to as the worst maritime ecological disaster in Sri Lanka’s history. The wreck is close to shore, too close, and it won’t be long before the effects of the ship’s fuel and other pollutants are felt, along with the cocktail of cargoes (some hazardous) from close to 1,500 containers the ship was carrying. The world watched with horror. Neighbouring governments rushed to offer assistance. Brave salvage teams did what they could. Concerned maritime and environmental organisations wrung their hands – and the blazing ship filled our TV screens. For the general public, it was just another accident at sea, just another example of the nasty, polluting shipping industry carrying out its business, a business dominated by shady shell companies in far away places that don’t play by the rules. That’s the public’s perception, but they want the...
Read more

Nave Andromeda - Terror Alert on the UK Coast

Image
  questions must be asked and lessons learned Nave Andromeda It sounded dramatic and the media duly ramped it. The essential ingredients were all in the mix - a ruthless band of shady foreign hijackers (surely terrorists if not mere pirates?), a shady foreign tanker under a shady Liberian flag, and a SpecialForces operation. But when the facts were revealed there was no injury, no loss of life and no damage to property, and neither the Isle of Wight, Portsmouth nor Southampton were subjected to an apocalyptic attack. The drama proved to be nothing more than a woeful tale of human despair in the all too familiar shape of lost souls seeking a better life. We should be grateful for the professionalism of the special forces, but we must also question why it happened at all. Firstly, there are questions about the timescale of the military response and, secondly, there are questions about why stowaways were still on a ship that was a few miles from British shores when it had visited b...
Read more